Democratic leaders' shocking silence over attacks on Israel by fellow Dems – New York Post
Thanks for contacting us. We've received your submission.
We’ve often sounded alarms over fellow Democrats who demonize Israel. But lately, even our party’s establishment and its leaders have become complicit in the consequences — by failing to denounce these attacks. Voters need to demand that top officials from both parties speak up loudly.
Such attacks put Jews in tangible danger and threaten the United States’ and Israel’s national security, given that Israel is our closest ally and the only stable democracy in the Middle East.
The harshest rhetoric emanates from the party’s progressives. Yet the Democratic establishment increasingly seems OK with it. Even Vice President Kamala Harris, one of the most powerful Democrats, actually applauded a student who accused Israel of “ethnic genocide,” saying that the young woman’s “truth should not be suppressed.”
It’s shocking: The claim of “ethnic genocide” is patently false, and it’s used as a rallying cry by extremists who seek Israel’s destruction. It also plays into a vile, twisted anti-Semitic stereotype that the Jewish state — and by extension, the Jewish people — are oppressors. For Harris to have endorsed that is more than alarming.
And she’s hardly alone. Indeed, anti-Israel sentiment has even infiltrated US policymaking, sending an even louder message and carrying real consequences for Israel.
Just weeks before Harris’ comment, progressive Democrats successfully pressured House Speaker Nancy Pelosi to reject $1 billion in funding for Israel’s Iron Dome missile-defense system. A separate measure to fund it ultimately passed, yet Pelosi had sent a clear message: far-left, anti-Israel lawmakers have a voice at the highest ranks of Democratic policymaking.
Pelosi has also looked the other way when progressives sprout anti-Semitic rhetoric. In 2019, Rep. Ilhan Omar (D-Minn.) questioned American Jews’ loyalty to the United States, charging that US support of Israel was “all about the Benjamins” and playing into the anti-Semitic stereotype that Jews are financial schemers. Omar then pushed another slur, casting Jews as deceitful oppressors by saying Jewish Democrats were “not partners in justice.”
Pelosi said nothing, and Omar faced no repercussions: She kept her seat on the House Foreign Affairs Committee and continues to wield influence over the Democratic agenda.
To be sure, we don’t believe Pelosi is anti-Semitic or that she opposes Israel’s right to exist. Yet at times, she’s prioritized politics and holding her caucus together over standing up for Israel and the Jewish people.
The trouble is that turning a blind eye to such speech allows extremism to infiltrate the mainstream, with severe consequences. Pelosi and other top Democrats are putting Israel’s survival and the Jewish community at risk.
And though Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer (a Jewish-American himself) did denounce Omar’s remarks in 2019, he has recently aligned himself with the progressive left and, like Pelosi, has refrained from denouncing other unfair slams against Israel by fellow Democrats.
During the Hamas attacks on Israel in May 2021, for example, progressives called for an end to US military aid to Jerusalem; Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-Bx-Queens) even echoed the false accusation that Israel is an “apartheid state.” Neither Schumer nor Pelosi condemned it.
Schumer was also silent when Senate Foreign Relations Committee Chairman Bob Menendez (D-NJ) condemned both Israel and Palestinians in the same statement, suggesting a moral equivalence between them that’s neither logical nor supported by evidence.
Nor did Schumer voice support for Israel during the May conflict, either in an independent press release or his regular Senate floor remarks. Instead, he joined 28 other senators who called for a premature ceasefire that would’ve harmed Israel’s efforts to prevent Hamas from waging future attacks.
How does top Dems’ silence imperil Jews? Here’s one way: During the May conflict, the Anti-Defamation League recorded 305 incidents of anti-Semitism in the United States, a 115 percent increase from the same period last year.
It’s no coincidence. You can’t separate the rise in anti-Semitic violence from the growing influence of members in Congress who marginalize Israel, want to undermine Israel’s ability to defend itself and question the right of the Jewish state to exist without facing consequences from party leadership.
The attacks, and threats to Jews, won’t slow down unless Americans — regardless of party or religion — demand their leaders speak up.
Douglas Schoen is founder and partner in Schoen Cooperman Research, a polling and consulting firm. Andrew Stein is a former New York City Council president and state Assembly member.