Commentary: Anti-science mobs threaten democracy – The cordova Times
By Tim Bradner
For The Cordova Times
I’ve been re-reading Sinclair Lewis’ classic 1930s political novel “It Can’t Happen Here,” which is about a right-wing politician who becomes a demagogue and launches a fascist takeover of the United States.
In the light of Jan. 6 at the nation’s capitol, Lewis’s novel has special meaning.
Events at Anchorage’s municipal assembly recently should raise uneasy feelings about the future of our political system, too.
I won’t delve into the give-and-take over the indoor mask rule that was on the table. Others are writing about this, although I personally take the advice of health professionals that face masks reduce transmission of COVID-19, hospitalizations and deaths.
But beyond that, what took place at the assembly meeting and on Jan. 6 should be worrisome for those of us who really want to protect democracy.
Lewis set his story in America, but it was really about Nazi Germany, where Lewis lived and wrote in the years before World War II.
There are chilling parallels. I was struck by video footage of days of Anchorage’s assembly meetings where an unruly crowd protesting the indoor mask rule hurled shouts, insults and threats of violence to intimidate those they disagreed with.
Our newly elected mayor, David Bronson, and at least one assembly member, appeared to egg on the protestors. Finally, the mayor ordered security staff out of the chamber and for a barrier protecting assembly members to be removed, exposing assembly members to what was becoming a mob.
Raucous municipal meetings with pitchfork-bearing crowds are nothing new in our democracy, but the intensity of this was at a new level. A gun was found too when police arrested some protesters.
That an elected mayor acted to expose not just an elected assembly but others of the public to potential violence by removing security is, in my mind, grounds for removal.
The irony I can’t resist is this, however: The mob had a uniform – red shirts. This bunch won’t have read history or even much about contemporary world politics but red was the color of Lenin and Stalin, and today is the official color of the Communist regimes in China and North Korea.
Sinclair Lewis’s American dictator dressed his mob, who were later his storm troopers, in blue shirts. In real history Adolf Hitler dressed his in brown and Benito Mussolini’s wore black.
The tactics followed the pattern, too. Threats and intimidation came first. In Germany that was followed by smashed windows, and worse (This isn’t a partisan thing, either. Witness events in Portland, Ore.)
Is our mayor a demagogue-in-the-making?
What worries me are aspirations of his supporters to oust moderate and progressive-leaning assembly members who have opposing views. That said, government executives supporting friendly candidates in legislative elections is nothing new.
I am somewhat assured that this mayor won by the slimmest of margins, which means the electorate as a whole are more balanced.
But things can change. The power of social media manipulated to whip up the mob can’t be underestimated. People forget that Hitler and Mussolini were first elected. They became dictators later.
I am encouraged that we have a free press which is reporting vigorously on the events at the assembly meetings just as the events on Jan. 6 in Washington, D.C. were reported.
But how much does that count today?
What’s disappointing in that most people get information on public events from social media, which we now know is manipulated, thanks to the courage of a former Facebook employee blowing the whistle in testimony to Congress. We may be in a new, scary world.
Let me return briefly to the current controversy. We know masking for health reasons has been widely accepted in Asian societies for years. Going one step further, vaccine mandates to prevent diseases like smallpox have long been accepted in the U.S. and are often required by law, such as for school children.
My sense is that politicians are stirring the pot over face masks and vaccinations to gain an edge.
It’s a cynical calculation, and it won’t work in the long run. Big employers on the national level are now mandating vaccinations, whether required or not, and employees are accepting them, an example is the 98.5% compliance so far at United Airlines.
In the long run, most people will get the shots and much of this will pass, I believe.
But besides the manipulation, the anti-science and anti-expert biases in our society that underpin the current controversies are a cause for worry. For one thing, they impede progress toward the direst threat we face, which is climate change.
Science will win eventually. It took years for people to accept that the world isn’t flat, and Galileo’s argument that the earth does not revolve around the sun but the other way around.
Belief is a powerful force, however. I met a woman in eastern Kentucky who was sincere and sweet and convinced that astronauts going into space was a hoax.
It was impossible, she believed, because if they had really gone up, they would have seen the angels.
Tim Bradner is publisher of the Alaska Legislative Digest and Alaska Economic Report.
Last Updated on Oct 25 2021, 2:53 pm AKDT
Weather by NOAA
Current Conditions: Overcast
Wind: North at 0mph
Your 5-Day Forecast at a Glance
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.